So from what I've heard the Robocop remake sucked. It was pretty apparant it would when you heard the movie wouldn't be as wonderfully gory as the original. But, enough negativity, let's do something positive. Like my all time favorite remakes of video games. Which, unlike the film industry, can actually be pretty damn good. I'm more avoiding the fresh coat of paint ones though, so I can get real remakes though. Ones that take the basis of the original and revamp them for something more modern. Basically, they don't just look different like Halo Anniversary, they play and feel different too.
5. Mega Man: Powered Up
My favorite Mega Man game, it took the original and never stopped asking the question "How can we make this more fun?" From letting you play as bosses (complete with Mega Man as the boss for their stage" to an interesting level editor, Powered Up is a top notch remake from a time when Capcom was still awesome.
4. Tomb Raider Anniversary
Taking the original Tomb Raider and giving it those smooth controls found in Legend obviously would require for quite a different approach. Luckily, Crystal Dynamics really stepped up, with great puzzles and platforming, creating an experience far more engaging than last year's reboot. Also its Croft Manor is one of the best things ever.
3. Counter Strike Source
CS went just enough above and beyond to be one of the best remakes ever. Rather than just taking new maps and tweaking them so they can improve any flaws the original had. The result is a game I spent more time with than every other online FPS combined.
2. Metroid: Zero Mission
The original Metroid was great for its time, but also a product of its time. Part of this comes from the limitations of the NES while the other part is from how Super Metroid was better in every way. But Zero Mission brought the original to a new generation by doing what a remake should: take the basics from the game and tweak them so they make a more fun and modern playing experience. The fast pace and fun of Zero Mission makes it my favorite entry in the series.
1. Pokemon Heartgold/Soulsilver
Before this, my favorite entry in the Pokemon series was a tie between Crystal and Platinum. On one hand, the 2nd generation had an entire region to explore after you beat the Elite 4 and at the time, probably the most diverse roster of catchable Pokemon before you beat the game. But on the other hand, 4th generation improved the interface so much and perfected the mechanics with the physical/special split and nerfing stall teams, which were absurdly overpowered before.
Then comes the 2nd gen remakes. Not only does it have everything good about Gold, Silver, and Crystal, but it takes those perfect mechanics and fits them in perfectly. But that's not all, it perfects the interface in a way the series has stupidly abandoned since. And it also lets you have any Pokemon you want follow behind you everywhere. And it's the only Pokemon that introduced new minigames I legitimately enjoyed. Yeah, this is a perfect remake.
I would also add :
Lunar: Silver Star Story (PSP)
Tactics Ogre (PSP)
Resident Evil 1 REmake (Gamecube)
Never played any of those.
Resident Evil is the king dingaling of video game remakes, imo. The visuals still hold up and it remains a creepy game.
RE's visuals do still look good today, but I just don't like the controls of any pre-4 RE game. I get why people like those games, just not for me.
Wind Waker HD was incredible, and Super Mario All-Stars on SNES was also a great remake.
WWHD was incredible. If it added a dungeon or something to that effect I'd probably put it on here.
Bionic Command: ReArmed was good. I can't really think of any others.
Rearmed was awesome.
Mega Man Powered Up is one of my favorite PSP games.
Sounds like I should have bought Tomb Raider trilogy for PS3 instead of getting the new one. I can easily find that game for $20.
I have always wanted to try Metroid Zero Mission as well.
All the games in the collection are much better than the reboot.
Zero Mission was definitely a lot more accessible than the first one as well. Damn respawning enemies that can pass through doors ...
The original's just something I'll never be able to get into. A lot of old NES games are like that.
Heartgold's one of my favorite Pokemon games. Played a few Metroid games,but Zero Mission was the best I played.
Robocop movie sucked? DAMN. I was hoping for the best, but I knew it would be bad.
That sucks for the new Robocop. I love the original. Pokemon Crystal is my favorite pokemon game ever it is amazing. But since you mention Soul Silver and Heart Gold, I might have to check them out.
It may not have done much else than update the graphics (in truly impressive fashion) but I felt Halo CE Anniversary was a great remake.
I heard the new Robocop suffers mostly from a shitty script. I suspect the PG-13 rating is the least of its problems. It'll probably become just as dispensable as that Total Recall remake.
I played the Halo Anniversary and thought it was cool, but I ended up playing that Firefight map built with the Reach engine more than anything else.
Tomb Raider Anniversary is the one TR game I didn't play. I figured I already played the original, why play it again. I do want to own a copy and give the new controls a try.
I didn't know Metroid Zero Mission was a remake? I need to look into that one.
